Instagram Comment Giveaway: How to Pick a Winner Fairly (Rules, Proof, US Taxes)
Updated 2026-11-19
1. Post the rules first
Instagram makes the person running a promotion responsible for its rules and for running it lawfully. Put the following in the giveaway post or a pinned first comment and there’s little left to argue about later.
- Dates: start and end, with a time zone (e.g. ends Dec 20 at 11:59 p.m. ET)
- How to enter: follow, comment, or whatever counts as an entry
- Number of winners and backups, and when and how you’ll announce them (DM, post)
- Who can’t enter: you, employees and their households, and multiple accounts of one person
- Duplicate entries: whether several comments count once
- Eligibility: minimum age (18 or older is common) and where you can ship, e.g. legal residents of the 50 US states and DC
- The prize and its approximate retail value
- “No purchase necessary. A purchase does not improve your chances of winning.”
- Instagram release: “This promotion is in no way sponsored, endorsed or administered by, or associated with, Instagram. Entrants release Instagram from any liability.”
2. What not to do
- Don’t require a purchase. In the US, a prize plus chance plus a required purchase makes the giveaway an illegal lottery.
- Don’t ask people to tag themselves in a photo they aren’t in. Instagram’s promotion guidelines ban inaccurate tagging.
- Don’t change the rules after the deadline or decide the winner before the draw.
- If a brand supplied the prize, say so plainly in the post.
3. Collect the comments
- Log in to instagram.com on a computer and open the giveaway post. The app can’t copy comments in bulk.
- Click ⊕ (load more comments) until it disappears. If replies count as entries, open “View replies” too.
- Drag-select from the first comment to the last, copy, and paste into the Giveaway picker. You can paste in several batches; overlapping comments are removed automatically.
With thousands of comments, some can be skipped while loading. After pasting, check that the entry count is close to the post’s comment count.
4. Clean up and draw
- Turn on “One entry per person”. Turn it off only if your rules allow multiple entries.
- Put your own and staff accounts in “Leave out”. Tap any username that was picked up by mistake to remove it.
- Set the number of winners and backups and tap “Draw winners”. Winners come from the browser’s secure random numbers, so even the host can’t steer the result.
- Start your phone’s screen recording and go from pasting to drawing in one take. If anyone questions the result, you have a video.
5. Announce and send the prize
- Use “Copy announcement” for the winners post, then DM each winner.
- Ask only for what shipping needs (name, contact, address), say what it’s for and when you’ll delete it, and delete it once the prize arrives.
- If a winner doesn’t reply by your deadline, move to the backups in order. Put this deadline in the rules too.
Prize value and US taxes
| Prizes per winner, per year | What you do |
|---|---|
| Under $2,000 (2026) | No Form 1099-MISC needed. The winner still owes tax on the prize’s value. |
| $2,000 or more | Collect a Form W-9 (including a tax ID number) and send the winner a Form 1099-MISC |
The threshold was $600 for prizes awarded through 2025, and it adjusts for inflation from 2027. Separately, if your total prize pool is over $5,000 and New York or Florida residents can enter, those states require you to register and post a bond before the giveaway starts; small giveaways usually keep prizes under $5,000 or exclude those states. This is general information, not legal or tax advice.
Open the tool →FAQ
- Can only followers win?
- The picker doesn’t check who follows you. When a winner is drawn, check their follow yourself and, if they don’t qualify, move to a backup as your rules say.
- Can I make tagging a friend a condition?
- Asking people to mention a friend in a comment is common. Asking them to tag people in a photo they aren’t in goes against Instagram’s guidelines, and asking for lots of tags looks like spam.
- Can I redraw if I don’t like the result?
- Redrawing because you didn’t like the winner breaks the fairness of the draw. Move to a backup only when a winner isn’t eligible or doesn’t reply.
Sources
- Instagram Help Center — Promotion guidelines
- Gleam — Instagram giveaway rules and what official rules should cover
- KickoffLabs — Instagram giveaway rules 2026 (no-purchase statement, eligibility)
- Woobox — Instagram giveaway compliance (purchase required makes an illegal lottery)
- JD Supra (Venable) — New prize tax rules raise the 1099 threshold to $2,000
- EY Tax News — Treasury proposed regulations on the $2,000 reporting threshold (May 14, 2026)
- Klein Moynihan Turco — sweepstakes registration and bonding in New York and Florida over $5,000
Checked on: 2026-11-18